Wednesday, March 4, 2015

The Cure for Discontent?

During our symposium on Monday, we talked about whether it would be morally right to give everyone a pill to make them happy. Although this seems like a good idea on the surface, once you look at it a little closer, you see the consequences of doing this. Not only is it morally wrong if you do not tell citizens about it, I also believe that someone who would do this is failing to see people as people. Rather than seeing them as individuals, they see them as means to gain the "perfect society," one where everyone is happy and content to live the life they have. Because people would be content with what they have, and not be greedy or jealous, some of the problems that society faces today, such as crime, could be greatly reduced. However, if people are content with what they have, will they also lose their passion and drive to succeed? Who is going to be inspired and driven enough to go through the demands of medical school to become a doctor? Or work carefully to build their small business into a successful company? Or invent a new product that would make life easier? Would people even have the drive to get an education and work at all, or would they be content with living in poverty, just doing enough to get by? If the world was on a "happy pill," many of the great discoveries and inventions that have been made throughout history, and are continually being made, would not have occurred. People would be ok with living their lives as they are, and would see no need for improvement. However, it is the discontent, the dissatisfaction with the status quo, that fuels the advancement in all aspects of our lives.

5 comments:

  1. I agree with your theory about not being driven if we are on the happy pill. Being content can leave people to not want to strive for something greater than themselves. I would not want the pill because it would not reach my highest pleasure to keep my human dignity, like Mill said.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your post. If you lie to someone and make them take the pill, you are not seeing people as people. Also, I believe that if you are on the happy pill there would be discoveries that would not have occurred. You have to fail to achieve greatness and if you are on the pill you would not fail and possibly not succeed. People need to feel like they need to go the extra step and do something with their lives. There is always room for improvement. I agree with you completely.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the pill would not be beneficial. Yes, the outcome would be great, but it is about the process and how you get there that is the most important. According to Kant, it is your duty to pursue happiness through reason, as long as you're not lying.

    ReplyDelete
  4. While the happy pill sounds great, I do have to agree that perhaps if there is only contentment, people would not strive to improve on imperfections. Things in our society that are not perfect may still be there but if there is no discontent or unhappiness, would anyone do anything to try to correct those things that are wrong. Just because you have a happy pill does not mean that there would be no bad things occurring but that people would perhaps not care about these things. So, I think Sheridan bring up an important point, that one's drive to succeed or to make improvements may be diminished if we were all on a happy pill.

    ReplyDelete
  5. While the happy pill sounds great, I do have to agree that perhaps if there is only contentment, people would not strive to improve on imperfections. Things in our society that are not perfect may still be there but if there is no discontent or unhappiness, would anyone do anything to try to correct those things that are wrong. Just because you have a happy pill does not mean that there would be no bad things occurring but that people would perhaps not care about these things. So, I think Sheridan bring up an important point, that one's drive to succeed or to make improvements may be diminished if we were all on a happy pill.

    ReplyDelete