According to Webster online, Karma (in Hinduism and
Buddhism) is defined as “the sum of a person's actions in this and previous
states of existence, viewed as deciding their fate in future existences.” This definition
is used worldwide as “What goes around, comes around”. Karma can be a good
thing, like for instance if you donate to a charity or feed a homeless man on a
corner, you may find a twenty dollar bill on the ground or get a free meal from
your favorite restaurant. Karma could also be a bad thing, for example if you
tease a homeless man with food or maybe break someone’s heart; you may find
that your spouse cheated on you with your best friend or may have a flat in the
rain. Where am I going with this? Well, in the short film we watched last week
called White Bear, a lady and her fiancé were charged for torturing a little
girl. Her fiancé did all the torturing, she just recorded. For her sentence,
she was sent to this kind of Amusement park called White Bear Justice Park and
there, she was given the same treatment as the little girl. The only difference
it happened to her every day for 3 weeks. They would have her wake up, chase
her around the park, which she thought was a town, humiliate her in front of a
group of people, and then clear her brain with this little device of all the
memories she had of that day. Now, depending on your definition of Justice and
Morality how would you define this scenario? Is it just? Is it moral? Why or
why not? Also, in a case such as this, would you consider this to be the Karma
that she deserves?
I believe that she deserves punishment but I do not agree with out they treated her doing over and over again. The karma she deserves could be a different form of punishment where she knows what she did was wrong. Since her memory was wiped she does not know what truly happened therefore it was not successful. In class, we discussed that it could be just because it was proportional and fair. However, I agree that just and morality should be pushed closer together. I do not believe that is was moral.
ReplyDelete