Wednesday, November 4, 2015
Alienated Labor
In Karl Marx's theory on class struggle violence, he claims that because capitalism is built on the exploitation of labor, it is inevitable that the poor will become poorer and more numerous, whereas the rich will become richer and fewer. A 2014 Oxfam report noted that one percent of the population held 48% of the total global wealth. This does not, however, mean that the other 52% belongs to the rest of the population, because in actuality, it is mostly controlled and owned by the other 20% of the wealthiest people. Ultimately, this means that approximately 5.5% of global wealth belongs to the other 80% of people (i.e., us). For further clarification, the vast majority of the world's population owns less than six percent of the global wealth. As Marx noted, this means that we are all essentially competing with each other for 5.5% of wealth when we, the 80%, likely produce 99% of the labor. Another interesting thing about Marx's theories of labor concerns one of the four reasons that workers are alienated. The one I find most compelling with regards to the previously mentioned statistics is the one that states that under capitalism, workers become alienated from themselves. For example, when work is imposed, it makes the labor a miserable task. In psychology, there is a concept known as the over-justification effect that states that when the compensation for a task is too high or too low, it undermines the intrinsic motivation to do the task. Numerous research studies (See Deci, 1970 for an example) have shown that when people who do not receive compensation for a task tend to report more positive experiences than people who were paid. I think this is a pretty clear example of how putting a price on our labor diminishes the intrinsic gratification we would get from doing something that should be a conscious and free activity.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This is written very well! I really like the fact that you mention the over-justification effect. I think that we definitely do this as a society. I know of many people who say that they aren't in their career for the money. I think that they justify their low wages because at least they are doing something that they enjoy. I am definitely guilty of doing this with my current job and with my future career. I remember saying that even though I could make more money as a waitress than I do as an afterschool worker that at least I enjoy what I am doing. Is it possible I am trying to justify why I work where I work? If I were given no wages would I be even more grateful?
ReplyDeleteI agree with you! People are least like themselves when they are at work because it is the only animal like activities we do. Work leaves the mind physically and mentally drained. You are right that 20% of the population controls the poor. Society today does seem to compete with each other. People do tend to report more positive positive experiences when they receive compensation. The price on our labor does diminish the gratification. Great post and well said!
ReplyDelete